The Best Protein Bars by Goal: Macros, Ingredients, and Price Compared

If you’re trying to hit your protein target without blowing your calories, or just want a bar that won’t wreck your stomach, the “best” protein bar depends on what you’re after.

Some bars pack the most protein per calorie. Some skip sugar alcohols entirely. Some load up on fiber, and some just cost less.

So which bar actually fits your goal, and which numbers on the label matter?

Below, I’ll match six bars to six goals, walk through their macros, sugar alcohols, collagen, and price per bar, and tell you what I noticed eating and baking with the ones I’ve tried. (Here’s how we review products.)

FeastGood may earn a commission from links on this page.

The short answer, by goal:

  • Most protein per calorie: David
  • No sugar alcohols or artificial sweeteners: Transparent Labs Grass-Fed Protein+ Bars (closer to a mini-meal; still has added sugar) Check price
  • Highest fiber: Quest
  • Budget: Pure Protein
  • Lowest calorie: BUILT Puff
  • High protein with no added sugar: Barebells

Key Takeaways

  • Protein as a share of calories ranges from 21% (TL Grass-Fed Protein+) to 75% (David).
  • Four of the six bars list sugar alcohols. Maltitol is the one to watch, and tolerance varies a lot from person to person.
  • David, Barebells, Pure Protein, and BUILT include collagen, and none say how much. It counts toward the protein on the label, but it seems to be less useful for building muscle.
  • Price per bar runs from $1.79 (Pure Protein) to $3.33 (TL Grass-Fed Protein+).

Quick Comparison

Bar (flavor) Best for kcal Protein Protein % of kcal Fiber Sugar (added) Sugar alcohol Collagen? $/bar Link
TL Grass-Fed Protein+ (PB Choc Chip) No sugar alcohols or artificial sweeteners 280 15 g 21% 3 g 10 g (5) None No collagen in protein source list $3.33 ($3.00 sub) Check price
David (Choc Chip Cookie Dough) Most protein per calorie 150 28 g 75% 2 g 0 g 7 g Yes $3.25 davidprotein.com
Barebells High Protein (Cookie Captain) High protein with no added sugar 220 28 g 51% 2 g 2 g (0) 7 g (maltitol) Yes $3.08 barebells.com
Quest (Apple Pie) Highest fiber 170 20 g 47% 13 g 2 g (0) 7 g (erythritol) No collagen in protein source list $2.96 (12-ct) questnutrition.com
Pure Protein (Chocolate Deluxe) Budget 180 21 g 47% 2 g 3 g (2) 4 g Yes $1.79 pureprotein.com
BUILT Puff (Coconut) Lowest calorie 140 17 g 49% 0 g 6 g (6) None Yes $2.50 built.com

Macros are for the listed flavor only. Protein % of kcal = protein grams × 4 ÷ calories (FeastGood calculation). Prices are list prices on October 13, 2026.

Bar chart of share of calories from protein: David 75 percent, Barebells 51 percent, BUILT Puff 49 percent, Quest 47 percent, Pure Protein 47 percent, Transparent Labs Grass-Fed Protein+ bar 21 percent.

How I Chose These Bars

I only included bars where I could get the brand’s full nutrition panel. Then I compared them on five things:

  1. Protein per calorie. How much of the bar’s energy comes from protein.
  2. Sugar alcohols. Whether the bar uses them, and which kind.
  3. Protein source. Including whether collagen is in the blend.
  4. Fiber.
  5. Price per bar at list price.

IQBAR, No Cow, RXBAR, and Kirkland didn’t make the cut because I couldn’t get a full nutrition panel for them. That’s not a knock on those bars.

I’ve eaten the Transparent Labs, Barebells, and Quest bars, just not the exact flavors in the table, so my notes are about each brand’s bars in general. I picked David, Pure Protein, and BUILT Puff on the label alone.

Each pick is the best match for one goal, not an overall ranking.

The Picks

Transparent Labs Grass-Fed Protein+ Bars: Best If You Want No Sugar Alcohols or Artificial Sweeteners

Best for: people who want a bar without sugar alcohols or artificial sweeteners. It’s not sugar-free, though. This flavor has 10 g of sugar, and 5 g of that is added.

Label highlights (Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip, 60 g) – 280 calories, 15 g protein, 23 g carbs, 3 g fiber – 10 g sugar (5 g added), 16 g fat (5 g saturated), 280 mg sodium – No sugar alcohols or artificial sweeteners – Protein from whey isolate plus egg white

Drawbacks – Lowest protein per calorie in this group: 15 g for 280 calories, or 21% – 10 g of sugar (5 g added) and 16 g of fat – Highest price per bar here – Contains peanuts, milk, and egg

Think of it as more of a mini-meal or snack than a lean protein hit. If you want the most protein for the fewest calories, go with David instead. Macros vary slightly by flavor (15–16 g protein).

Price: $39.99 for 12, or $3.33 per bar. Subscribing drops it to $35.99, or $3.00 per bar.

Check Transparent Labs Grass-Fed Protein+ price

What I noticed: With so many protein bars trying to taste like candy, I liked that this one tastes like real food. It kept me full, too, so it works as a post-workout or between-meal snack. It’s dense and chewy, though, and I wanted a drink with it. Warming the pieces in the air fryer crisped the edges and improved the texture.

In a side-by-side comparison, I preferred Barebells for protein content, taste, and texture; see the Barebells pick below.

For more detail, see our Transparent Labs protein bar review and Transparent Labs vs Barebells.

David: Most Protein Per Calorie

Best for: getting the most protein for the fewest calories.

Label highlights (Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, 62 g) – 150 calories, 28 g protein (75% of calories) – 2 g fat, 12 g carbs, 2 g fiber, 160 mg sodium – 0 g sugar, 7 g sugar alcohol – Protein from milk protein isolate, collagen, whey, and egg white – Gluten free

Drawbacks – Sweetened with maltitol, allulose, sucralose, and acesulfame K – Collagen is part of the protein blend, and the amount isn’t disclosed – Contains milk and egg

Price: $39.00 for a 12-bar carton, or $3.25 per bar.

If maximum protein is your goal, also see our list of protein bars with the most protein.

Barebells High Protein: High Protein With No Added Sugar

Best for: people who want 28 g of protein with no added sugar (2 g total sugar), and who tolerate maltitol.

Label highlights (Cookie Captain, 60 g) – 220 calories, 28 g protein (51% of calories) – 16 g carbs, 2 g fiber, 7 g fat (3.5 g saturated) – 2 g sugar (0 added), 7 g sugar alcohol (maltitol) – Protein from a milk protein blend, bovine collagen hydrolysate, and soy protein isolate

Drawbacks – Carries a laxative warning for maltitol – More calories than David for the same 28 g of protein – Collagen is in the protein blend, and the amount isn’t disclosed – Contains milk and soy

Price: $36.99 for a 12-pack, or $3.08 per bar. Barebells’ soft bars are a separate line with 16 g of protein.

What I noticed: The gooey center, crunchy bits, and chocolate coating eat a lot like a Snickers bar, and they’re good straight out of the wrapper. Two minutes in the air fryer makes them even better, and the warm chunks are great on ice cream, yogurt, or oatmeal.

In a separate test, with no flavor recorded, I found Barebells taste a lot like a regular candy bar, and sometimes they’re too sweet for me.

Quest: Highest Fiber

Best for: people who want lots of fiber and low net carbs.

Label highlights (Apple Pie, 60 g) – 170 calories, 20 g protein (47% of calories) – 24 g carbs, including 13 g fiber – 2 g sugar (0 added), 7 g sugar alcohols (erythritol), 6 g fat – Also sweetened with sucralose and stevia – Protein from milk and whey protein isolate

Drawbacks – 7 g of sugar alcohols per bar, though erythritol tends to be better tolerated than maltitol – Contains milk, almonds, and soy – Macros vary by flavor

Price: $35.49 for 12 ($2.96 per bar), or $12.49 for 4 ($3.12 per bar).

What I noticed: I’ve been a Quest fan for a long time. I love the mix-ins, like chocolate chips, cookie dough, marshmallows, and sprinkles, and Quest is my favorite brand for baking with protein.

Pure Protein: Budget Pick

Best for: the lowest price per bar.

Label highlights (Chocolate Deluxe, 50 g) – 180 calories, 21 g protein (47% of calories) – 4.5 g fat (3.5 g saturated), 17 g carbs, 2 g fiber – 3 g sugar (2 g added), 4 g sugar alcohol

Drawbacks – Uses maltitol – Contains hydrolyzed collagen

Price: $21.49 for 12, or $1.79 per bar. A 4-pack is $7.99.

BUILT Puff: Lowest Calorie

Best for: keeping calories down.

Label highlights (Coconut, 40 g) – 140 calories, 17 g protein (49% of calories) – 3 g fat, 13 g carbs, 0 g fiber – 6 g sugar, all added – No sugar alcohols – Certified gluten free

Drawbacks – 6 g of added sugar – Protein comes from partially hydrolyzed whey isolate plus collagen, and the collagen share isn’t disclosed – Contains gelatin – No fiber

Price: $29.99 for 12, or $2.50 per bar.

For more low-calorie options, see our lists of protein bars under 200 calories and protein bars under 100 calories.

Sugar Alcohols: Should You Avoid Them?

Not necessarily. It depends on your gut.

Sugar alcohols (polyols) can upset your stomach, and the more you eat, the more likely that gets, though people vary a lot. Erythritol is about 90% absorbed in the small intestine, so it tends to cause fewer problems than the others.

Maltitol is the one to watch. In a small study of healthy adults, 30–40 g of maltitol in chocolate caused some mild gas and rumbling, but no real laxative effect. On average, people didn’t hit diarrhea or severe symptoms until about 92 g a day.

A single bar here has 4–7 g of sugar alcohol, which is well under that. Barebells still carries a laxative warning for maltitol.

If you know sugar alcohols bother you, two bars here have none: Transparent Labs Grass-Fed Protein+ and BUILT Puff.

For more options, see our list of the best protein bars without sugar alcohols. This is general information, not medical advice.

Collagen and “Label Protein”

Here’s a catch most people miss. The protein number on the label counts all protein the same, but collagen doesn’t work like whey or milk protein.

Collagen is missing the amino acid tryptophan, so it’s an incomplete protein. In a trial with older women, whey raised muscle protein synthesis (your body’s muscle-building process) and collagen didn’t.

A trial with older men found the same thing: an extra 50 g a day of whey or pea protein raised muscle protein synthesis, but collagen didn’t.

So if a bar’s protein count is padded with collagen, it may do less for your muscles than the label makes it look.

David, Barebells, Pure Protein, and BUILT all use collagen, and none of them say how much of the protein it makes up. TL Grass-Fed Protein+ and Quest have no collagen in their protein source lists.

For more, read our comparison of collagen vs whey protein.

More Protein Bar Lists

This guide picks one bar per goal. For deeper lists, see:

  • Protein bars under 200 calories
  • Protein bars with the most protein
  • Best protein bars under 100 calories
  • Best protein bars without sugar alcohols
  • Best low-fiber protein bars

Related reads: protein bar vs shake and eating protein bars every day.

Verdict

  • Most protein per calorie: David (28 g protein, 150 calories)
  • No sugar alcohols or artificial sweeteners: Transparent Labs Grass-Fed Protein+ Bars, more of a mini-meal with some added sugar
  • Highest fiber: Quest (13 g)
  • Budget: Pure Protein ($1.79 per bar)
  • Lowest calorie: BUILT Puff (140 calories)
  • High protein, no added sugar: Barebells (28 g protein)

Pick based on your goal, and check the label on the exact flavor you buy, since the macros change from flavor to flavor.

Best if you want no sugar alcohols: Check Transparent Labs Grass-Fed Protein+ price

Sources

  1. Transparent Labs Grass-Fed Protein+ Bars product page. https://www.transparentlabs.com/products/protein-bars
  2. Transparent Labs Grass-Fed Protein+ Bar, Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip nutrition label. https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/0866/7664/files/P_-_Peanut_Butter_Chocolate_Chip_SFP_1200x1200_1.png
  3. David Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough product page. https://www.davidprotein.com/products/chocolate-chip-cookie-dough-carton
  4. David Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough nutrition label. https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/0632/4741/7511/files/CCCDNutrition.png
  5. Barebells Cookie Captain. https://shop.barebells.com/products/barebells-cookie-captain
  6. Quest Apple Pie Protein Bar. https://www.questnutrition.com/products/apple-pie-protein-bars
  7. Pure Protein Chocolate Deluxe product page. https://www.pureprotein.com/products/chocolate-deluxe-protein-bar
  8. Pure Protein Chocolate Deluxe label. https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/0507/0218/8716/files/2_PP_Amazon_ChocolateDeluxe_12_LabelImage.jpg
  9. BUILT Puff Coconut product page. https://built.com/products/coconut-puffs-12ct
  10. BUILT Puff Coconut nutrition label. https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/0119/4829/4202/files/Puff_Coconut_Stack_12CT_NFP_250717.jpg
  11. Systematic review on polyols and GI tolerance. Advances in Nutrition. https://advances.nutrition.org/article/S2161-8313(22)00690-1/fulltext
  12. Maltitol tolerance study in healthy adults. https://www.nature.com/articles/1601516
  13. Whey vs collagen and muscle protein synthesis in older women. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7049534/
  14. Whey, pea, and collagen in older men. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38762187/
author avatar
Jared Lauber
Jared is a two-time 50-mile ultramarathon finisher, Boston Marathon qualifier, and former NCCAA All-American who reviews nutrition products to help athletes fuel performance, recovery, and long-term health. Jared is a two-time 50-mile ultramarathon finisher, Boston Marathon qualifier, and former NCCAA All-American who reviews nutrition products to help athletes fuel performance, recovery, and long-term health.

Leave a Comment